Social Media is Like Cheese Pizza
Social Media Isn’t A Marketing Strategy
Relying solely on social media to market your business is like only eating cheese pizza.
Is cheese pizza good?
Obviously.
But if it’s the only thing you eat for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, you’re missing out on a massive menu of better options, and frankly, you’re going to end up malnourished.
You’ve just posted a reel. It got 10,000 views, 500 likes, and a handful of fire emojis in the comments. You feel like a marketing genius and your dopamine receptors are firing.
Now, look at your bank account.
Notice how those fire emojis didn’t automatically pay your rent?
That’s because vanity metrics are a hell of a drug, but a terrible business strategy.
Relying solely on social media to market your business is short-sighted, incredibly risky, and a guaranteed ticket to a very stressful, ultimately unsuccessful business model.
Social media is a single cog in a larger engine. If you aren’t factoring in newsletters, blogs, ads, and direct outreach, you don’t have a marketing ecosystem; you have a fragile hobby.
The Goldfish Myth
You know the oft-quoted stat of people having the attention span of a goldfish? First of all, that study was fake.
Goldfish actually have great memories and decent focus. The algorithm doesn’t.
Organic posts have terrible reach and only last in the feed for a couple of hours. And that’s IF the viewer has engaged with your content in the past few days.
Plus, seeing a post, no matter how engaging it is, isn’t going to get a cold prospect to buy your highest ticket service.
The Illusion of “Owning” an Audience
You’ve heard this before – you do not own your followers. Mark Zuckerberg does. Or Elon Musk does on the days he isn’t busy rebranding everything or causing an uproar over his latest opinion. (Do NOT get us started…..)
If the platform goes down, so does your audience. You have no way to talk to them.
Unless you’ve built a properly integrated marketing system.
But wait, you say, doesn’t your company create social media content for your clients?
Yup. We do. And we continually have the conversation with them about “what ELSE are you doing?” Social media is great, but it can’t be everything.
The Ecosystem: What You Actually Need to Factor In
A good integrated marketing strategy means expanding your palate. If social media is the cheese pizza, these are the other essential items you need to factor in to actually sustain your business:
Blog:
The shelf-life of a social media post is measured in hours – or less. It’s a content treadmill, always trying to stay ahead of the latest algorithm change or newest trend. Meanwhile, a high-quality, search-optimized blog post sits on your website and quietly brings you high-intent traffic from Google for three years. It builds authority while you sleep. (Plus, you can repurpose it for social media!)
Website:
Social media posts (hopefully) bring people to your website. They open the door – now it’s up to YOU to make them want to come inside. (There’s a whole other article waiting here about how to make your website inviting and about brand consistency etc. Stay tuned….)
Newsletter:
If you meet someone, have a great time, and then never speak to them again…..you’ve just ghosted your next client. Whether it’s a formal newsletter or a friendly “hi” email every quarter, you need regular communications to stay in touch and build a relationship. This is your REAL audience – people who have given you their email, bought a product or service, and who have a true interest in you. Watching their engagement stats will tell you who’s likely to buy or who’s at risk of leaving.
Ads:
Social media platforms are “pay to play”. If you want to find new people, you need to run ads. Meta is a great, low-cost to entry platform to do this. You target the audience, craft the message, and monitor the results. It’s measurable and quantifiable. And consider ads outside of social media, too. Google Search ads on a very specific keyword phrase can be incredibly effective. Running an ad in an association newsletter or on a related website gets you in front of a lot of like-minded prospects. Consider print ads – yes, they still work – or even radio.
💡Pro tip💡: Don’t try to write an organic post to make it “ad-like”. If it looks like a duck and sounds like a duck…..the algorithm says, “Hang on, this is a duck! Er……ad! DEPRIORITIZE!” If you try to sneak an ad pitch into a regular post without paying for it, the platform will crush your reach.
Outreach:
Direct outreach – whether that’s cold email, networking, or picking up the actual phone – puts you in control. And when you reach out directly, your social media and website act as a background check to prove you aren’t a bot.
Social media:
Your organic social media is proof of who you work with, how you help them, and who you are. Maybe the client finds you on social first, but it’s often the case that people see you outside of social media and then check to see if you’re on Instagram. Sometimes they do this BEFORE they even go to your website.
The Connected Journey
Social media is an important part of an integrated plan, but if it’s all you’re doing, you’ve set yourself up for a very long, frustrating, and incredibly boring journey.
When you have all the parts working together, you get to demonstrate who you are beyond grid posts on a profile. You get multiple touchpoints, better data, and a business that survives when Instagram inevitably crashes for six hours.
Social media is great. Keep posting.
But stop expecting a single slice of cheese pizza to do the job of a fully catered, multi-course marketing engine.
Put down the ring light. Order something else off the menu.
(May we recommend Hawaiian??)



